Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

About Catherine

Catherine Hotaling Nyack, NY Real Estate Agent Headshot

Catherine Hotaling

Get To Know Me

I strive to guide buyers and sellers through every step of their real estate journey - making the process as seamless, informed, and successful as possible.
 
My background in sales and marketing from the fashion and television industries gives me a unique edge in understanding style, trends, and market positioning. I combine this with deep industry knowledge to help clients make confident, well-informed decisions.
 
As your buyer's agent, I aim to be a thoughtful sounding board, taking the time to understand your needs, concerns, and aspirations. My mission is to help you find a home that feels both aspirational and attainable - one that supports your lifestyle and brings long-term happiness.
 
Throughout my career, I've built a reputation as a supportive and calming presence. I'm here not just to facilitate a transaction but to ensure your experience is smooth, enjoyable, and rooted in trust. With the strength of the Sotheby's brand behind us, and a commitment to innovation and heritage, I'm proud to help clients navigate the market with clarity and ease.
 
Let's work together to unlock your vision of living well.
WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Excellent service! Smooth transition from renter to owner! Grateful for Cathy’s expertise!

— Janine P.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Cathy was so essential to our house search. She was helpful, flexible, resourceful, and professional - really helped us figure out what we needed as we went, and was especially helpful with negotiating. So knowledgeable and a genuine person. We couldn't have done this without her! Highly, highly recommend.

— Nick C.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Cathy was a great asset in helping us meet our goal and purchase our first family home before the summer of this year. She always made herself available to show us numerous homes and was there until the very last minute of signing and getting our keys. Thank you again for your services and help till the end.

— Lucie M.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Cathy was an incredible agent to work with! My husband and I began our home search in the peak of the post-pandemic real estate craziness, and throughout our search, Cathy continued to go above and beyond to help us find our starter home. She was always quick to respond, frequently sent us new listings, went with us to many showings, and was our guide throughout the whole process. Thank you, Cathy, for f...

— Kara M.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Cathy is the best! She said we would find our home, and she was right! She helped at every step above and beyond!

— Ben P.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Cathy was amazing to work with. She believed in our dream of having a home and helped us find a place we love. She’s patient and non-judgmental. Really supportive and kind!

— Bushra R.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

We had a wonderful experience with Catherine Hotaling, Ellis Sotheby's International Realty. She coordinated with another agent to show us the one property that we wanted to see at the last minute. Cathy is very personable and is responsive in providing quick and reliable answers to our inquiries. Consistently checking in and seeing if we have any questions. We used the inspection professional as well as...

— Anna Y.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

We can't express enough gratitude for Catherine Hotaling from Ellis Sotheby's International Realty. Her expertise, availability, and resourcefulness made our home-buying journey seamless and an absolute pleasure to work with. From the moment we met, Caithy was energetic and down to earth, immediately making sure we were getting the best while ensuring a smooth and stress-free experience for all parties i...

— Elena G.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

A Diamond in the Rough. Cathy makes up for all the subpar realtors out there. I bought my Nyack house from her in 2020, and she has rented for me since. Having her as a realtor and resource is a home and property owner's dream. She is exceptional in her honesty, genuine care, diligence, hard work, and unmatched kindness. I've since moved to CA, and I wish I could clone her!

— Amy M.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Cathy is extremely knowledgeable about the lower Hudson region. She helped us buy an amazing house in Palisades and then sell the house at a significant profit a few years later when our situation changed, and we had to move again. Cathy is always available and easy to work with. We highly recommend Cathy to anyone looking to buy or sell a house in Rockland, Westchester, or wherever else you can get Cath...

— Jackson L.

View All

Notable Sales

Sold

1 Sugarhill Road
$1,250,000

1 Sugarhill Road, Nyack, NY 10960

  • 4 BEDS
  • 3 BATHS
  • 2,804 Sq.Ft.

Sold

2220 State Route 17A
$1,200,000

2220 State Route 17A, Goshen, NY 10924

  • 4 BEDS
  • 4 BATHS
  • 3,774 Sq.Ft.

Sold

611 Gateway Avenue
$785,000

611 Gateway Avenue, Valley Cottage, NY 10989

  • 4 BEDS
  • 4 BATHS
  • 2,039 Sq.Ft.

Sold

6 Horne Tooke Road
$760,000

6 Horne Tooke Road, Palisades, NY 10964

  • 3 BEDS
  • 2 BATHS
  • 1,596 Sq.Ft.

Sold

15 Westend Avenue
$750,000

15 Westend Avenue, Nyack, NY 10960

  • 3 BEDS
  • 3 BATHS
  • 1,712 Sq.Ft.
View All

Find Out Your Dream Home

See Home Value

Let’s Find Your Dream Home

A thoughtful, client-focused approach and strong understanding of market positioning shape every real estate experience. Drawing on a background in sales, marketing, and design-driven industries, Catherine helps buyers and sellers navigate important decisions with confidence, clarity, and personalized guidance.

Let's Connect

Get in Touch

contact-form-background

Contact Details

CATHERINE HOTALING

[email protected]
845.536.1313 

ADDRESS 76 N Broadway Nyack, NY 10960