Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

2220 State Route 17A
Courtesy of Ellis Sotheby's Intl Realty, Catherine Hotaling Listing Contact: 845-353-4250 
$1,200,000

2220 State Route 17A

4 Beds 4 Baths 3,774 Sq.Ft. 5 Acres

Description

One of the original Goshen farms, built c.1770-1775, and where condensed milk was invented, this Federal-Style Colonial has been meticulously restored down to every period-correct detail with no expense spared. The 5-acre estate features the Main House, Dairy Barn, Root Cellar w Loft, 2-car Garage, Tool Shed, & Chicken Coop.
Updates encompass everything - a full restoration starting from the 1993 and continuing to this day, including: 8 fireplaces (7 gas and working, 1 orig Ben Franklin decorative) - new electric from the pole throughout the house - gas line to street - plumbing - boiler - water heater - drilled well - gutters - roof - all custom millwork throughout - hand-painted Delft tiles - all metal roofs - hand laid stone wall no mortar - carport - hardwood floors - 3 room basement with poured concrete floors. Not one creak or crack in this perfectly kept home, the quality of which is rarely seen.
As you enter though the wide center hall, to one side is the living room, with custom-crafted archways over the windows and a warming fireplace. This leads into the adjoining sitting room with another gas fireplace. Across the hall is the banquet-sized formal dining room with the third fireplace and featuring an exquisite 12-arm custom Waterford chandelier. From here you enter the eat-in kitchen featuring the immense and warming AGA cast iron cooker and the fourth gas fireplace.
A graceful hardwood staircase ascends from the first to the third floor, with spacious landings along the way. The second level features four generously sized bedrooms, two with ensuite full bathrooms and two which share a Jack n Jill full bathroom. And of course, each bedroom has its own cozy and unique fireplace. A sun-drenched library and a convenient laundry closet complete this level.
On the third floor, you'll find a spacious attic with high ceilings, multiple windows that invite natural light, and a separate bonus room, perfect for a variety of uses. The full, unfinished basement offers three rooms for ample and dry storage.
This home, offering sublime privacy and tranquility, has been elegantly decorated and many of the antiques and period-correct furniture can be negotiated.
Whether you're savoring sunsets from the front porch or admiring the brilliance of the night sky in your backyard, this serene retreat - truly a piece of Goshen history - provides the perfect balance of nature and comfort.

Share Property

Location

2220 State Route 17A, Goshen, NY 10924

Status

Sold

Date Sold

May 12, 2026
Catherine  Hotaling

Catherine Hotaling

TITLE

REALTOR®

Property Amenities

Interior
Fireplace Gas
Appliances Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Oven, Refrigerator, Washer, Gas Water Heater
Flooring Combination, Hardwood
Total Bedrooms: 4
Half Bathrooms: 1
Full Bathrooms: 3
Other Interior Features Chefs Kitchen, Crown Molding, Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Formal Dining, Kitchen Island, Original Details, Pantry
Area & Lot
Lot Area 5 Acres
Living area 3,774 Sq.Ft.
MLS® ID 802577
Year Built 1775
School District Goshen
High School Goshen Central High School
Middle School C J Hooker Middle School
Elementary School Goshen Intermediate
View Description Mountain(s),Panoramic,Trees/Woods
Architecture Styles Colonial, Mini Estate
Type Residential
Status Sold
Exterior
Stories 3
Air conditioning None
Heat type Natural Gas
Water Source Well
Garage Space 2.0
Sewer Septic Tank
Parking Carport, Detached, Driveway, Garage
Lot Features Back Yard, Front Yard, Stone/Brick Wall, Views
Utilities Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected, Trash Collection Public
Finance
Sales Price $1,200,000
Real Estate Tax $11,900 yearly

360 Virtual Tour

Take a tour of this property

Let’s Find Your Dream Home

A thoughtful, client-focused approach and strong understanding of market positioning shape every real estate experience. Drawing on a background in sales, marketing, and design-driven industries, Catherine helps buyers and sellers navigate important decisions with confidence, clarity, and personalized guidance.