An ivory clapboard Cape with dark windows and a blue door beyond a deep autumn lawn, with a bluestone walk and golden maple.

Clarkstown's Proposed Preservation Tax Is Billed as a Closing Fee. Who Would Actually Pay It in Valley Cottage?

November 5, 2026

The Town of Clarkstown describes its Community Preservation Act as "a one-time .75% fee on real estate closings," paid by the buyer.

None of it is being collected yet, either. Voters still have to approve it, and the town now says that referendum will happen next year.

What Albany Actually Signed

The enabling law is Assembly bill A11349, with Senate companion S10276. It was sponsored by Assemblyman Patrick Carroll and signed as Chapter 191 on July 31, 2026. The town credited Governor Kathy Hochul, Carroll and Senator Bill Weber in its August 10 announcement.

The bill text on the New York State Senate site sets out three features of the proposal:

  • The rate is a ceiling. The town may adopt a tax "not to exceed" 0.75% of the price, and its own local law has to fix the actual rate.
  • Voters decide. Any local law imposing the tax goes to a mandatory referendum.
  • The exemption. The law allows an exemption "equal to the median sales price of residential real property within the applicable county," as determined by the state under Real Property Tax Law section 425.

Rockland's Residential Sale Prices

New York's Department of Taxation and Finance publishes the county medians that section 425 points to. On the state's residential median table, Rockland's figure is $780,000 for 2025, based on 1,928 sales. It was $746,300 in 2024 and $665,000 in 2023. The state counts only arm's-length residential sales coded as non-condominium.

Compare that with what is selling now. OneKey MLS reports a Rockland single-family median of $800,000 for the third quarter of 2026, across 508 closed sales. The condominium median for the same quarter was $516,500. In September 2026 alone, the single-family median was $795,000.

Orangetown Chose a Lower Rate and a Much Smaller Exemption

Tappan, Blauvelt, Pearl River and Piermont sit in Orangetown, which went down this road first. The comparison makes the Clarkstown design clearer. Orangetown's Town Board adopted Local Law 3-C on July 14, 2026. It sets a 0.3% tax paid by the purchaser, with a flat $100,000 exemption for improved property and $50,000 for unimproved land. The law could take effect only if voters approved it, and the town put it on the November 3 ballot as Proposition 2.

When It Could Touch a Closing

Nothing changes at a Clarkstown closing today, and several steps have to happen first.

  1. A referendum. In June, the town said it was aiming for this November. Its October 7 survey page now says the act "will be put to a voter referendum next year." Mid-Hudson News reported the same timing on October 8.
  2. A plan before the vote. The statute requires a community preservation project plan listing specific projects and parcels, completed at least 60 days before the referendum. Fund spending is limited to projects on that plan.
  3. A local law that sets the rate. That rate could be anywhere up to 0.75%.
  4. A start date. The tax applies from the first of a month the Town Board designates, at least 60 days after the local law is enacted.

The state updates the county median each year, and Rockland's has risen in each of the last two years shown.

What the Money Would Buy, Closer to Home

The town's assessor estimated the tax would raise nearly $5 million a year, held in a dedicated fund. Under the statute, that money can go to open space, parks, farmland, wetlands, aquifer recharge areas, wildlife habitat, public access and historic properties. No more than 10% can go to stewardship of land already protected. A Community Preservation Board of five or seven unpaid members, most with conservation experience, would advise on purchases.

Valley Cottage already has an example of this kind of purchase. The town points to the Bear Swamp Preserve and Nature Trail, where a land acquisition created a connection to the Long Path. Which parcels a future fund would prioritize is the board's job, and the board has not been formed yet.

The tax is part of a wider pause. In September, the Town Board adopted a six-month moratorium on approvals for multifamily housing, large subdivisions and larger commercial and industrial projects. It can be extended by six more months. The town says new zoning will take into account the Route 303 & 304 Safety and Sustainability Study, which it describes as close to finished.

Is Anything Being Collected Yet?

There is no local rate, no start date and no referendum result yet. For background on how Valley Cottage compares with nearby New City and Congers, the neighborhood pages are a good next stop.

This post is general information about how the law is written, not legal, tax or financial advice. Before you rely on any figure here, check your own purchase or sale with your attorney or tax professional.

Let’s Find Your Dream Home

A thoughtful, client-focused approach and strong understanding of market positioning shape every real estate experience. Drawing on a background in sales, marketing, and design-driven industries, Catherine helps buyers and sellers navigate important decisions with confidence, clarity, and personalized guidance.